Apologies to readers, this article is a little longer than usual. It’s because I thought on this occasion to detail some of the evidence supporting my contentions. That section can easily be skimmed.
PM Burnham appears to have moved closer to formally declaring Zionism UK state ideology. Informally, it is virtually there already.
The IHRA (International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance) definition of antisemitism, along with its eleven working examples, is the vehicle of choice for solidifying UK state capture by Israel and its supporting lobbyists.
It’s likely that readers of my articles are well versed in an appreciation of the unstated, yet weaponised intent of the IHRA – to shield Israel from criticism, to air brush its demonic character and actions – so I will not burden you with a repetition of critiques probably well-known to you. One example will suffice. (There are others, here[1] and here[2])
Geoffrey Robertson KC, in a 2018 Opinion[3] made clear that the ‘IHRA definition of antisemitism is not fit for purpose
The definition does not cover the most insidious forms of hostility to Jewish people, and the looseness of the definition is liable to chill legitimate criticisms of the state of Israel and coverage of human rights abuses against Palestinians….’a particular problem with the IHRA definition is that it is likely in practice to chill free speech, by raising expectations of pro-Israeli groups that they can successfully object to legitimate criticism of Israel and correspondingly arouse fears in NGO’s and student bodies that they will have events banned, or else will have to incur considerable expense to protect them by taking legal action. Either way, they may not organise such events.’
This 2018 legal Opinion, in 2026, now seems an act of prophesy, for much of what was feared, has come to pass. The IHRA has insinuated itself into vast swathes of governmental, public and institutional life, spearheaded by Israel lobbyists, notably the Jewish Establishment comprising organisations such as the Board of Deputies of British Jews (BoD), something called the Jewish Leadership Council, the Community Security Trust (SCT) and others, depending where one draws the line.
Below are some of the areas where the IHRA has taken hold, in some places more actively than others. However, the list, almost certainly incomplete, does begin to map the territory taken by the IHRA. Because a key purpose of the IHRA is to constrain and direct speech, it represents a real and current danger to UK political and civic life, extending to schools, higher and further education. In other words, so far as education is concerned, the IHRA creates the conditions for misleading up-and-coming generations about Israel, Zionism, antisemitism.
IHRA tentacles reach far
The Labour, Conservative and LibDem parties have adopted the IHRA definition of antisemitism along with its eleven ‘non-binding’ examples.
More insidiously, when the UK Government adopted the definition in December 2016, it took effect across all ministerial departments—including the Home Office, Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office, Ministry of Justice, Department for Education, Department of Health and Social Care, Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government.
IHRA tentacles have reached further:
- Crown Prosecution Service (CPS). Adopted the definition alongside central government departments in December 2016 and circulated it to specialist hate crime prosecutors.
- It is used across UK policing—including the Metropolitan Police and regional constabularies.
- NHS England formally adopted the definition and wrote to individual NHS trusts encouraging local adoption.
- Following ministerial requests in 2025, executive agencies and arm’s-length bodies overseen by the Department of Health and Social Care have also adopted the definition.
- Over 270 regional, local, and municipal authorities across the UK—including the City of London Corporation and county/borough councils—have passed motions adopting the definition.
- Because universities and colleges are autonomous, each institution decides on adoption individually. According to the Office for Students (OfS) and parliamentary records, 245 higher education providers in England (including the vast majority of UK universities) have formally adopted the definition.
- University of Oxford, University of Cambridge, University College London (UCL), King’s College London, University of Edinburgh, University of Birmingham, Durham University, University of Exeter, University of Liverpool, University of Nottingham, University of Southampton, University of York, and Queen Mary University of London.
It is a shocking list, but goes to my assertion that Israel, along with its flotilla of support craft, including the hyperactive, Jewish Establishment, has, in effect, achieved state capture by a foreign entity, Israel.
Zionism is racism: You better not believe it
So infected by what must now be considered a fetishistic, deviant relationship with Israel, the UK Prime Minister, Andy Burnham, thought it right to put his weight and that of the government behind (i) a condemnation of the Green Party’s endorsement of the Zionism is Racism motion and (ii) further, and more worrying, declaring that local authority councils that had come to joint Green Party/Labour Party agreements to govern locally, Labour councillors must withdraw as a consequence of the Green Party motion.
For an added element of chutzpa, Burnham declared he would tolerate local Green/Labour Party agreements so long as Green Party councillors renounce the democratically endorsed Zionism is Racism conference motion.
Again, this goes to the assertion that Zionism is, or is becoming, UK-State ideology. The doctrine appears to have achieved state-protected status, enabling it to play a highly questionable role in UK political life. Thus, Phil Rosenberg, President of the BoD made this lobby group’s position clear:
“Today, representatives of Jewish communities across Britain have delivered a clear verdict. By adopting an antisemitic platform, the Green Party of England and Wales has become a racist party. We will treat it accordingly.
This statement is closely aligned with PM Burnham’s line:
Prime Minister Andy Burnham condemned the Green Party’s ‘Zionism is racism’ motion as ‘wrong’ and ‘antisemitic’ during Prime Minister’s Questions
The Jewish Leadership Council and Israeli embassy carry on in much the same way, labelling the Green’s motion antisemitic and racist. (It can’t escape comment that Israel and its lobbyists accusing the Green’s of racism is surely a case of the pot calling the kettle black. But I suspect this irony eludes them.)
It’s not clear whether Rosenberg had prepared Burnham’s script, but this was probably not required as Burnham seems to have imbibed Zionism of his own volition.
If Burnham, and indeed Labour Party Chair, Bridget Phillipson, aimed to placate Israel and its lobbyists by aping their positions, they have succeeded. Karen Newman, Vice President of the Board of Deputies of British Jews, praised Labour’s firm stance, stating ‘that the organization had been actively pressing for this commitment’.
Zionism: Racist or not?
So here we have a British organisation – the BoD – promoting the particular interests of a foreign state, Israel. The BoD, and its flotilla of supportive entities, regularly intervenes when Israel’s interests are thought to be threatened, for example, when our Foreign Secretary announced sanctions[4] against West Bank settlements.
Obvious questions arise: Does the Jewish Establishment:
- stray into working to secure Israel’s advantage at the expense of UK interests?
- accord primacy to Israel’s interests against those of British Jews?
It’s worth noting that the Jewish Establishment formally represent, say, only 40% of UK Jews (probably a generous figure). Certainly, a significant part of Anglo-Jewry deprecates the Jewish Establishment’s stance on the Green’s Zionism is Racism motion. And even more pointedly, Jews in an Open Letter to the Board of Deputies accuse it of denying the genocide perpetrated by Israel against the Palestinians. The letter, in a short space of time, has 250 Jewish signatories (including me). The letter was robust, pulling no punches[5]:
We Jews assert that the Green Party is not racist for passing a motion linking Zionism with racism. We accuse the Board of Deputies of British Jews of genocide denial. We urge it to desist.
We Jews, including many Jewish members of the Green Party, are writing to condemn your motion calling the Green Party racist. We abhor all antisemitism, all racism, all discrimination.
You had tried to discredit the evidence of Israel’s apartheid. You know that Israel was a close ally of apartheid South Africa. Its apartheid was named by the towering figure of Archbishop Desmond Tutu. You ignored the 2021 report from B’Tselem…which characterised the apartheid of the Israeli administration: “a regime of Jewish supremacy from the river to the sea”. You rubbished the conclusions of reports on Israel’s apartheid from Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch.
We Jews should be wary of condemning and ridiculing human rights organisations, given their emergence after the horrors of the second world war. We need their protection, too.
We can add two other sources in support of the Green party motion. Sources that were surely put in front of Burnham at some point by Government researchers and/or the Labour Party leader’s internal support staff.
Two Jewish historians, Avi Shlaim (emeritus professor of international relations at Oxford University) and Illan Pappe (Israeli historian and professor at the University of Exeter) have independently come to the evidence-based conclusions that:
- (Shlaim) Zionism is a racist ideology largely responsible for the Nakba (the displacement and dispossession of Palestinians in 1948). He points to the July 2018 Nation-State Law—which asserts a unique right to self-determination for Jews—as formalizing an exclusionary hierarchy that denies equal status to Arab citizens. Shlaim describes the Israeli regime as a system of Jewish supremacy ‘from the river to the sea’…
- Pappé argues that Zionism is driven by the logic of elimination of the native, aiming to take over as much of Palestine as possible while minimizing or displacing the indigenous Palestinian population. He details how Zionist leaders systematically planned and executed the expulsion of roughly half of the Palestinian population and destroyed hundreds of villages in 1948.
Foreign policy consequences
So far as the UK relationship with Israel is concerned, Burnham has tied himself in knots. On the one hand, his Foreign Secretary, Ed Miliband,[6] seems to want to steer UK policy away from uncritical support of Israel. Yet Burnham appears to be aiming for the opposite. Miliband set out his store at the recent Labour Party conference:
‘I want to say to the millions of people in this country and indeed elsewhere who have been moved and outraged by the plight of the Palestinian people: we hear you, you were right
‘And under Andy’s leadership, we have reset our approach. We call out ethnic cleansing by the settler terrorists in the West Bank. We call out the evidence of war crimes in Gaza. We call out Israel’s illegal occupation of Palestine. And we match words with actions.’
It is not at all clear that ‘under Andy’s leadership’, the Labour Government has reset its approach. Indeed, Burnham, having so extravagantly followed the DoB’s position that Zionism is not a form of racism, and agreeing that to deny this is antisemitic, has neutered himself in any engagement with Israel. Having somewhat noisily disavowed the essential nature of Israel, he can hardly say anything meaningful about its treatment of Palestinians within Israel and also within the OPT.
The Miliband quotes suggest a fundamental incompatibility with the Burnham approach. It’s not clear how this can be resolved.
Indoctrinating younger generations: Sir David Bell’s ‘independent’ review of antisemitism in schools and colleges
As indicated above, at the behest of Government, the IHRA is infesting wider and wider areas of institutional life. As with any state-authorised doctrine, a key objective is to inculcate up-and-coming generations in what are intended to be state sponsored orthodoxies, in this case the IHRA. This has profound consequences, for a key feature of the IHRA is its focus on policing what it is acceptable to say about Israel, Zionism, antisemitism, Palestinians, and what is not. In the light of this, we must be concerned at the findings and consequences of an ‘independent’ review of antisemitism in schools and colleges.
In October 2026, Sir David Bell conducted what was called an ‘independent’ review of antisemitism in schools and colleges. One of his twenty-seven recommendations was that the IHRA working definition of antisemitism should be officially adopted and applied. This is bad enough, and goes to my assertion that the IHRA, a pro-Zionist text, can be seen as an aspect of UK state capture by Zionist thinking, granting the IHRA protected status.
According to Bell, Jewish children need special protection from a ‘distinct form of harm,’ that is antisemitism.
The Good Law Project has issued a legal challenge against the report, in particular the recommendation that schools and colleges must adopt the IHRA.
Jo Maugham of the Good Law Project:
‘What we really want is for government to be consistent in how it tackles hate speech…The rules that apply to one minoritised group should also be the rules that are applied to other minoritised groups… Consistency is what we want.’
In lockstep with this position is Na’amod[7] – a movement of Jews seeking to end ‘our community’s support for Israel’s occupation and apartheid’ – making the key strategic point that:
‘Antisemitism should not be taught as exceptional…It should be taught alongside racism and Islamophobia, because these struggles are bound together and the people who fight one are the natural allies of those who fight the others…Treating antisemitism as a special case with its own rulebook prevents that learning and sets Jewish safety apart from everyone else’s.’
‘Its [the IHRA] examples run criticism of Israel together with hatred of Jews, and in universities it has overwhelmingly been used to censor speech about Israel rather than to protect Jews.’
The government risks teaching Jewish pupils that support for Israel is integral to their identity, and that Palestine solidarity is inherently threatening.
It may be worth noting that Middle East Eye raises a question as to Sir Bell’s independence. It reported that[8]:
Bell’s appointment as an “independent” reviewer sits uneasily with his background. He previously served as permanent secretary at the Department for Education and chief inspector of schools in England.
Sir Bell is listed as having sat on the National Council of the Academic Study Group on Israel and the Middle East, whose mission is to ‘initiate or expand active links and research collaboration between academics, specialists and centres-of-excellence in the UK and their counterparts in Israel’. Its director, John Levy, has longstanding ties to the Friends of Israel Educational Foundation and Academic Friends of Israel….It is also notable that, in 2005, Bell was accused of Islamophobia while head of Ofsted, after he said that Muslim schools risked undermining social cohesion.
We are no exception, other than to the extent we are all exceptions
Exceptionalising us -Jews – is first, a profound attack on the very idea that we are all part of a shared humanity and that all racisms are equally bad, though the form racism takes, and who is the victim may vary from one time to another. Exceptionalising Jews goes against this fundamental principle of a shared humanity. Moreover, it constitutes a danger to Jews because it gives the impression, by implication at the very least, that such prejudice as we experience – significantly less that that endured by other minoritised groups – is somehow more important, more significant, than that experienced by, say, Muslims, Roma and young black males. It is not.
Given the spread of institutions and government departments required to become entangled in the IHRA net and noting that a key purpose of the IHRA is to shield Israel from scrutiny, one can see how the British state is sailing close to Zionism becoming government policy, unnamed, not admitted, but affecting decisions, nonetheless. We can conceive this as UK state capture by a foreign entity, Israel, and its supporting lobbyists.
[1] https://www.doughtystreet.co.uk/news/ihra-definition-antisemitism-not-fit-purpose
[2] https://knightcolumbia.org/content/a-bad-deal-why-using-the-ihra-definition-of-antisemitism-on-campus-is-incompatible-with-academic-freedom-and-students-right-to-open-inquiry
[3] https://www.doughtystreet.co.uk/news/ihra-definition-antisemitism-not-fit-purpose
[4] https://bod.org.uk/bod-news/board-of-deputies-expresses-deep-regret-at-government-announcement-of-sanctions-targeting-israeli-settlements/
[5] https://jewishvoiceforliberation.org.uk/article/the-board-of-deputies-of-british-jews-stands-accused-of-genocide-denial/
[6] https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/we-hear-you-you-were-right-ed-miliband-tells-people-outraged-over-palestinian-plight
[7] https://jewishvoiceforliberation.org.uk/article/government-challenged-over-ihra-antisemitism-definition-in-schools/
[8] https://www.middleeasteye.net/opinion/how-uk-antisemitism-report-could-worsen-very-problem-it-warns-against
Leave a Reply