Arthur Batram kindly commented on my last piece, ‘On Evidence. On the Political’. (See the comments section after that article) For reasons that I hope will become clear if you care to read on, I thought that his piece too rich simply to leave a short comment-type reply. So, in a scatter-gun sort of way, I’ve tried to respond to his musings.
But if you’re looking for sustained argument on one topic in what follows, turn away now, you will not find it here.
Thank you for what Word Press defines as a ‘comment’ (this on my piece ‘On Evidence. On the Political’).
It is in fact not a ‘comment’, so much as a stream of consciousness laced with your customary erudition, tangential references, entertaining allusions, bewildering double-backs leading to what one assumed (hoped?) was the last – that is, final – thought only to find oneself in yet another wild flower meadow sown by your mind’s emissions.
For those readers who get to, say, word 505 of your ‘comment’, only to despair that there are another 1,090 to go (but who’s counting?) – read on! Patience can – mostly – be rewarded, certainly if one takes a look at the links and references. So thank you for the link to Professor of Theology James P Carse. Looks like a rich theme to explore, not least because he puts training in its place:
To be prepared against surprise is to be trained. To be prepared for surprise is to be educated. Education discovers an increasing richness in the past, because it sees what is unfinished there. Training regards the past as finished and the future as to be finished. Education leads to a continuing self-discovery; training leads to a final definition. Training repeats a completed past in the future. Education continues an unfinished past into the future (This from a paper about his work )
I think I have it right – no doubt you’ll correct me if required – when I say that your comments were a good deal to do with politics; in particular, the qualities – attitudes of mind – required to grapple with and oppose established configurations of power. Continue reading